My Honest Thoughts on Essay Rater After Using It in Oct 2025

I’m a postgraduate student in Communication Studies at UCLA, and I spend a lot of time writing essays, research papers, and reports. Even after proofreading multiple times, it’s easy to miss gaps in logic, weak arguments, or sentences that don’t flow well.

I’ve tried a bunch of grammar tools over the years — Grammarly, Hemingway, ProWritingAid — but honestly, none of them really gave me the kind of feedback I needed. They could catch spelling mistakes or clunky sentences, sure, but they didn’t tell me if my essay actually made sense or whether my argument was strong enough. That’s why I started looking for something smarter, something that could feel like a real writing partner. That’s when I found PerfectEssayWriter.ai Essay Rater, and I decided to give it a proper test in October 2025.

Why I Decided to Try an AI Essay Rater

So, here’s the thing: when I write essays, especially on topics like media theory or communication ethics, I need my points to flow logically. Every paragraph should support my thesis, and every argument needs evidence that actually makes sense. I realized that I was spending hours rewriting and rechecking things, but I wasn’t always confident that my essay was as good as it could be.

I wanted an AI tool that could do a few key things for me:

Check if my arguments made sense from start to finish

Highlight weak transitions or paragraphs that didn’t fully support my thesis

Give me scores similar to what a professor might give

Suggest ways to improve readability and structure without changing my style

Honestly, I was skeptical at first. I mean, can an AI really understand an essay like a human editor? But I was ready to find out.

First Impressions

The first time I uploaded my essay, I was actually impressed. The interface was clean, simple, and easy to navigate — no complicated menus or confusing buttons. Within seconds, I got a full report with scores across multiple areas:

Metric Score Description

Grammar Accuracy 98% Only minor punctuation issues

Coherence & Structure 9.6/10 My paragraphs flowed logically

Argument Strength 9.4/10 Evidence supported my thesis well

Clarity & Tone 9.2/10 Readable and professional

Overall Readability 88 Easy to understand and accessible

I remember looking at the feedback and realizing something — there was a paragraph I thought was perfectly fine, but the AI flagged it as not fully supporting my thesis. That was a “wow” moment for me because I honestly hadn’t noticed that issue myself.

How I Used It

Rubric-Based Feedback

I started with the Essay Rater rubric-based scoring. Honestly, it felt like having a mini professor looking over my shoulder. It didn’t just tell me “this sentence is wrong” — it explained why my arguments could be stronger and what I could do to improve coherence. I actually found myself learning from the feedback as I went along, which was amazing.

Deep Context Understanding

I tried this feature with an essay about media gatekeeping. The AI noticed that one of my points didn’t fully connect to my conclusion. Grammarly or Hemingway wouldn’t have caught that at all. I took the suggestion seriously, reworked the paragraph, and suddenly my essay felt much more cohesive.

Sentence Analysis Tool

I’m guilty of writing long, complicated sentences, especially when I’m explaining complex ideas. The Sentence Analysis Tool highlighted areas where I could split sentences, remove repetition, or add smoother transitions. At first, I thought, “Do I really need to break this up?” But then I read it aloud and realized it made my essay way easier to follow.

Content Improver

After fixing the structure and sentences, I ran my essay through the Content Improver. I was curious if it could make my introduction or topic sentences more engaging. The suggestions felt natural and didn’t change my voice — just made everything read cleaner and more polished. It honestly felt like having an editor sitting right next to me.

Why I Love Using This Tool

I quickly realized that this AI saved me a ton of time. What used to take me three or four days to perfect could now be done in less than 24 hours. But more than that, I could actually see why each change was suggested. It wasn’t just “fix this” — it was teaching me how to improve my writing.

I also found that I could use it for all sorts of writing: academic essays, blog posts, professional reports — it adapted to everything I threw at it. And the best part? I could track my scores over time and see actual measurable improvement. That was super motivating.

Things I Thought Were Drawbacks but Turned Out Positive

I noticed a couple of things that I initially thought might be drawbacks, but they ended up being huge benefits:

When I wrote creative or expressive sections, the AI suggested slightly more formal phrasing. At first, I thought, “Uh, that’s too stiff,” but then I realized it was teaching me how to make my writing professional and clear without losing my voice. It helped me strike a balance between style and clarity.

For technical or dense paragraphs, it is suggested to split long sentences. I hesitated at first, but after applying the suggestions, my writing was much easier to follow. I learned how to explain complex ideas without overwhelming the reader.

So what I thought might be a limitation actually became a learning opportunity. I felt like I was improving as a writer with every suggestion.

Comparing It to Other Tools

I also tested Grammarly, Hemingway, and ProWritingAid to see how they stacked up. Here’s what I found:

Grammarly fixed grammar really well but didn’t analyze argument flow or thesis clarity.

Hemingway improved readability but didn’t give any feedback on the logic of my paragraphs.

ProWritingAid offered more detailed feedback than Grammarly or Hemingway, but it was slower and less intuitive.

PerfectEssayWriter.ai combined everything — grammar, clarity, argument analysis, sentence suggestions, and content improvement — in one tool.

Honestly, after using it, I found myself relying on it for almost every essay because it saved me time and gave me confidence that my work was strong.

How the Tool Has Evolved

I had used earlier versions of PerfectEssayWriter.ai before. The older versions focused mainly on grammar and sentence correction. But the 2025 version? It’s a game-changer.

As one of the best AI Tools for Academics, it now evaluates argument flow, thesis clarity, paragraph structure, and evidence quality. I’ve noticed that when I upload my essays, it doesn’t just check for mistakes — it really analyzes how my arguments are built and how well my thesis connects to each paragraph.

The Sentence Analysis Tool is a new addition that helps me polish my writing while keeping my voice intact. Even complex sentences come out smoother and easier to read without losing meaning.

The interface is faster and more intuitive than ever, so uploading and analyzing essays takes almost no time. I can quickly move from draft to improved essay in a fraction of the time I used to spend.

It’s clear the developers are listening to feedback and designing the tool to meet the real needs of students, writers, and anyone using AI Tools for Academics. Using it has made my writing process more efficient, more precise, and frankly, a lot more enjoyable.

Measurable Improvements I Saw

I tested the tool on 10 essays across different subjects, and here’s what I noticed:

Grammar accuracy improved by around 4%

Coherence and structure improved by 0.8 points on a 10-point scale

Argument strength went up by 0.7 points

Clarity and tone improved by 0.6 points

Overall readability went up by 6 points

Seeing actual numbers like this was motivating. I could track my progress and see that using the AI was making a tangible difference in my writing.

Who I Think This Tool Is Perfect For

Honestly, it works for almost anyone:

Students who want stronger essays and faster feedback

Bloggers who want to make their writing more readable and engaging

Professional editors who want to save time without sacrificing quality

Publishing professionals who need to improve content standards quickly

For me, the biggest win was the combination of speed, accuracy, and actionable feedback. I felt like I had a writing partner who not only fixed mistakes but helped me grow as a writer.

My Verdict

If you’re serious about improving your writing, I can’t recommend PerfectEssayWriter.ai Essay Rater enough. It’s a one-stop tool for improving clarity, argument strength, structure, and readability, and it also acts as the best humanizer, making my writing feel natural and polished. For me, it saved time, taught me new skills, and made my essays feel professional.

I feel confident submitting my work now, knowing it has been analyzed with the same rigor a professor would use. It’s definitely become my go-to tool for writing, editing, and refining essays.